"It's The Best Hit Exchange In The Whole World!"

That's A Nice Anecdote. So Why Doesn't It Prove Anything?

Anecdotal evidence is information passed along by word-of-mouth but not documented scientifically. One of the scientific rules is that anecdotal evidence doesn't cut it.

You can't judge the effectiveness of a hit exchange based on the appearance of the website. It doesn't help just because someone says it's effective. The amount of members a hit exchange indicates it has can be misleading. What you need are facts.